Politics

[Dr Gloom 21847]

19 minutes ago, Gemmill said:

Long-Bailey guarantees another lost election, I reckon. There is no way the electorate will view her as a potential PM. Unless she massively grows into the role. 

She’s absolutely fucking useless, as are most of Corbyn’s front bench - Burgon, Gardiner, Abbot, Piddick etc etc.

The only credible candidates in the shadow cabinet are John McD, Kier Starmer and Emily Thornberry. 

Yvette Cooper is the most natural and electable leader in waiting but she’s no chance as she’s viewed as a Blairite - ditto Tom Watson - by all the new members, who will ultimately decide. 

[Dr Gloom 21847]

Forgive me for posting something from Guido, and once again about my pet subject, but this is an illuminating set of vox pops - watch till the end 

https://order-order.com/2019/12/05/corbynistas-react-think-corbyns-anti-semitism-said-boris/

[ewerk 30371]

50 minutes ago, Dr Gloom said:

Rebecca Wrong Daily 

Trademark it now. You’ll be set for life.

[PaddockLad 17124]

If it's a reasonably close run thing on Thursday but still a Tory majority I can't see Corbyn going. Who  in the cult going to tell him to fuck off? 

 

We could be entering  a sort of Tory "early nineties" stage. They should be sent packing but the media has done it's job as they did on 1992. This also means we need a major world wide finiacial fuck up that can be blamed firmly on Javid from which they never recover. Following that the Labour party need a moment of clarity where they elect Kier Starmer after disastrous European & local  election results around 2021/22. Is any of this likely? Not from where Unite leadership & Momentum are sitting at the moment, no. It's very, very unlikely...

[Dr Gloom 21847]

Boris has dodged Brillo but good to see other “MSM” interviewers stepping up to the plate

 

[Rayvin 5186]

3 hours ago, PaddockLad said:

If it's a reasonably close run thing on Thursday but still a Tory majority I can't see Corbyn going. Who  in the cult going to tell him to fuck off? 

 

We could be entering  a sort of Tory "early nineties" stage. They should be sent packing but the media has done it's job as they did on 1992. This also means we need a major world wide finiacial fuck up that can be blamed firmly on Javid from which they never recover. Following that the Labour party need a moment of clarity where they elect Kier Starmer after disastrous European & local  election results around 2021/22. Is any of this likely? Not from where Unite leadership & Momentum are sitting at the moment, no. It's very, very unlikely...

 

I genuinely think Corbyn will go of his own accord. He's too old for this now man, and was never all that interested in the position right from the start.

 

He'll hang about for a bit so Labour can transition smoothly, and then he'll go.

[Dr Gloom 21847]

A seamless transition to Burgon or Long Bailey 

[Rayvin 5186]

I imagine there will be a membership vote. Hard to see any kind of cult forming around anyone else.

[Gemmill 44498]

 

This would be AMAZING. 

 

 

[Dr Gloom 21847]

53 minutes ago, Rayvin said:

I imagine there will be a membership vote. Hard to see any kind of cult forming around anyone else.

The membership has been taken over by corbynistas. 

[Rayvin 5186]

10 minutes ago, Dr Gloom said:

The membership has been taken over by corbynistas. 

 

And who will they vote for once Corbyn is gone? They aren't a hive mind whatever the media might have decided. I think there will be more left wing candidates and a broader split of votes.

[Dr Gloom 21847]

34 minutes ago, Rayvin said:

 

And who will they vote for once Corbyn is gone? They aren't a hive mind whatever the media might have decided. I think there will be more left wing candidates and a broader split of votes.

Presumably another of Corbyn’s crew,  equally unelectable. RLB or Piddick. Best we could hope for is probably McDonnell

[Renton 21393]

3 minutes ago, Dr Gloom said:

Presumably another of Corbyn’s crew,  equally unelectable. RLB or Piddick. Best we could hope for is probably McDonnell

McDonnell is also unelectable. Nobody trusts a scouser. 

[ewerk 30371]

1 minute ago, Renton said:

McDonnell is also unelectable. Nobody trusts a scouser. 

He’s a better form of Corbyn. He comes with plenty of baggage but is more electable than Corbyn. Whether that is enough is debatable.

[Renton 21393]

10 minutes ago, ewerk said:

He’s a better form of Corbyn. He comes with plenty of baggage but is more electable than Corbyn. Whether that is enough is debatable.

 

I agree. Quite impressed by him personally but he's fucked by his baggage. 

[Rayvin 5186]

It's not going to be McDonnell

 

The man himself has said the next leader after Corbyn needs to be a woman, which effectively rules him out unless some very sudden developments take place.

[Renton 21393]

48 minutes ago, Rayvin said:

It's not going to be McDonnell

 

The man himself has said the next leader after Corbyn needs to be a woman, which effectively rules him out unless some very sudden developments take place.

 

Which in itself is ridiculous, halfing the potential candidates. Feels like it will be RLB by coronation. 

[Dr Gloom 21847]

Labour is finished if she’s the next leader.

If it has to be a woman Emily Thornberry is the best of Corbyn’s allies. Yvette Cooper is the best candidate - male or female. I like Jess Philips too. 

[Tom 14011]

Jess Phillips  

 

[Meenzer 15432]

She's dared to criticise the regime, she's got no chance.

[Rayvin 5186]

Jess Phillips doesn't have enough vision for it. Not sure who does in fairness but she's very much the kind of pragmatist that the centrists would get behind.

 

So no help at all, judging by Swinson's performance.

 

Yvette Cooper I have heard good things about and I think she's smart and capable. Not sure she's radical enough but maybe she could be...

[Renton 21393]

20 minutes ago, Rayvin said:

Jess Phillips doesn't have enough vision for it. Not sure who does in fairness but she's very much the kind of pragmatist that the centrists would get behind.

 

So no help at all, judging by Swinson's performance.

 

Yvette Cooper I have heard good things about and I think she's smart and capable. Not sure she's radical enough but maybe she could be...

 

This country is so fucked. How do you think radical politics on either side can unite the country? The only thing that can do that is a form of, yes, pragmatic centrism. But through a butterfly effect of unforseen consequences on both the Tory and Labour sides the centre has been hollowed out, it doesn't exist any more.

 

Your mistake is thinking its because its not popular with the electorate. I maintain its not, its because its not available to the electorate. The LDs are largely irrelevant in this, with FPtP they just aren't viable, so don't tell me Swinsons lack of support is evidence people don't want moderates in power.

 

Most people this election are voting to try to stop the party they don't want getting in power. Think about it. Will any Corbynite ever be able to command a majority?

[Rayvin 5186]

The world is burning, I'm not sure centrism is going to be enough.

 

On top of that, younger generations are seriously pissed off. Renting forever, retire at 75, no pension, probably no NHS, no freedom of movement, university debt. Is centrism going to fix all of that? Pandora's box is open. All centrism will do is find a compromise position between the far right and what used to be the actual centre.

 

It won't be enough.

[Rayvin 5186]

Actually I just read that the pragmatic centrist option will exist after all. Farage will rebrand as the Reform Party, promising (right of) centre politics that appeals to ordinary people, changes he voting system and generally makes everything great.

 

So there's always him.

[Gemmill 44498]

Jess Phillips is one of the few good things the Labour Party has going for it, but she's not a party leader or a PM. 

 

Thornberry, Cooper or Starmer are the choices that could win an election. So it won't be any of them.