Europe --- In or Out

[ewerk 30571]

4 minutes ago, Christmas Tree said:

 

Voted against every bit of Brexit legislation, come up with their own vague impossible shifting position and concentrated on trying to obstruct the whole process. 

 

This issue is is bigger than party politics, particularly given main votes and manifestos.

And which pieces of Brexit legislation have Labour voted down?

[Renton 21594]

2 minutes ago, Christmas Tree said:

 

 return of the screaming fanny. Go and have a lye down.

 

What do you disagree with? Are you telling me the ERG did not introduce a wrecking ball last night? This isn't mine but perhaps it will help you understand what has happened.

 

Quote

The CU amendment failing does not mean much in itself. However...

A backstop to safeguard the GFA and no hard border between NI and RoI is a requirement for an agreed orderly withdrawal. The withdrawal agreement is a requirement for a transition period. The transition period is a requirement for avoiding an immediate economic calamity in the UK.

The earlier ERG amendment on NI rules out the possibility of NI remaining in alignment with the RoI, if the rest of the UK diverges. Thus it will be possible to honour the GFA and avoid a hard Irish border only if the entire UK stays aligned with the EU, as in staying in the EEA and a CU, and the failed amendment would have imposed this on the government as the last backstop, if all else fails.

Taking the failed amendment as a test vote demonstrates, that Parliament would not go for the fully aligned Norway option. And the ERG NI-amendment already rules out the diverging but NI-backstopped Canada/CETA option. There no longer seems to be any other option available, but a hard Brexit effective immediately come end of next March, with a hard Irish border, and with no mutually agreed aspiration for a trade deal.

In short, the UK has firmly pointed a gun to its head, made sure it is loaded, removed the safety, and is threatening to blow its brains out after having popped some steroids. Just like your everyday casino economy.

 

[Dr Gloom 21913]

4 minutes ago, Christmas Tree said:

 

 return of the screaming fanny. Go and have a lye down.

yeah - lye down renton

[Christmas Tree 4725]

2 hours ago, ewerk said:

And which pieces of Brexit legislation have Labour voted down?

 

Against not down.

[ewerk 30571]

3 minutes ago, Christmas Tree said:

 

Against not down.

So they haven't actually done any damage to the Brexit process?

[Christmas Tree 4725]

2 hours ago, Renton said:

 

What do you disagree with? Are you telling me the ERG did not introduce a wrecking ball last night? This isn't mine but perhaps it will help you understand what has happened.

 

 

 

Im referring to your little tirade at the end. Usually follows a bottle of red but surely not at this time of the day.

 

Its one thing from the ever aggressive Alex whose life would be empty on here without someone to be sharpen his nails on, but I expect better from you, even given your Brexit sneering position of thickos and Gammons

 

 

 

 

[NJS 4378]

3 minutes ago, ewerk said:

So they haven't actually done any damage to the Brexit process?

Isn't this just numbers? 

 

Four or five rebels aside, if they can't beat the number of tory MPs with all their MPs voting- especially when their so called rebels don't actually rebel - what can they actually do? 

 

 

[Christmas Tree 4725]

3 minutes ago, ewerk said:

So they haven't actually done any damage to the Brexit process?

 

 

Yes, they could have voted in the commons as per their stated Brexit position and avoided a weak government having to give in to amendments from hard brexiteers or ultra remainers.

 

Neither party wants to remain so a sensible path should have been followed by both leading to a better Brexit and a stronger hand in negotiations.

[ewerk 30571]

1 minute ago, Christmas Tree said:

 

 

Yes, they could have voted in the commons as per their stated Brexit position and avoided a weak government having to give in to amendments from hard brexiteers or ultra remainers.

 

Neither party wants to remain so a sensible path should have been followed by both leading to a better Brexit and a stronger hand in negotiations.

At what point did Labour whip their MPs to oppose leaving the SM or the CU?

[ewerk 30571]

3 minutes ago, NJS said:

Isn't this just numbers? 

 

Four or five rebels aside, if they can't beat the number of tory MPs with all their MPs voting- especially when their so called rebels don't actually rebel - what can they actually do? 

 

 

They can't do much without a significant Tory rebellion. My points are to CT who reckons that Labour have gone back on their promises on Brexit, which of course they haven't.

[Christmas Tree 4725]

Just now, ewerk said:

They can't do much without a significant Tory rebellion. My points are to CT who reckons that Labour have gone back on their promises on Brexit, which of course they haven't.

 

I’m simply saying they could have worked with the government to get Brexit legislation through, rather than opposing everything and making the government vulnerable to the wings. 

 

 

[Alex 35068]

12 minutes ago, Christmas Tree said:

 

Im referring to your little tirade at the end. Usually follows a bottle of red but surely not at this time of the day.

 

Its one thing from the ever aggressive Alex whose life would be empty on here without someone to be sharpen his nails on, but I expect better from you, even given your Brexit sneering position of thickos and Gammons

 

 

 

 

The difference between you and I is that I would have absolutely no qualms about repeating anything on here to your face. And you know it

[ewerk 30571]

4 minutes ago, Christmas Tree said:

 

I’m simply saying they could have worked with the government to get Brexit legislation through, rather than opposing everything and making the government vulnerable to the wings. 

 

 

As I pointed out, they haven't opposed everything. It's something they've been criticised for on his board since the vote. The role of the opposition is to question the government and to hold them to account, not to nod through every policy they come up with. This is really basic stuff.

[Renton 21594]

13 minutes ago, Christmas Tree said:

 

Im referring to your little tirade at the end. Usually follows a bottle of red but surely not at this time of the day.

 

Its one thing from the ever aggressive Alex whose life would be empty on here without someone to be sharpen his nails on, but I expect better from you, even given your Brexit sneering position of thickos and Gammons

 

 

 

 

 

Not sure why like, I'm always calling you out as a cunt when you act like one. Blaming this fiasco on Labour is as good an example of your wummery as you can get. It's ludicrous and you know it.

 

I also love how brexiters get so, oh Fuck it, let's say snowflakish, when they're called thick. A lot claim their being patronised is the reason they voted leave in the first place. Well, you can't get much more thick than that. I love the gammon description, it's perfect. 

[Christmas Tree 4725]

1 hour ago, Alex said:

The difference between you and I is that I would have absolutely no qualms about repeating anything on here to your face. And you know it

 

No, the difference between you and I is class. You have none. Can I suggest you reach for the ignore feature.

[Andrew 4748]

There it is folks, I think we can all agree that this thread has stepped it up to a new level and that it deserves a place in the gold section  

 

Class...class, what is it about that word that is jogging my memory...classy, classier!

Thats it classier, I'm sure I've heard some group or other refer to themselves as such when compared to Newcastle fans.

[Alex 35068]

8 minutes ago, Christmas Tree said:

 

No, the difference between you and I is class. You have none. Can I suggest you reach for the ignore feature.

[Kevin Carr's Gloves 3888]

Well that last bit of advice by CT was the most intelligent thing he has ever posted.

[Renton 21594]

14 minutes ago, Andrew said:

There it is folks, I think we can all agree that this thread has stepped it up to a new level and that it deserves a place in the gold section  

 

Class...class, what is it about that word that is jogging my memory...classy, classier!

Thats it classier, I'm sure I've heard some group or other refer to themselves as such when compared to Newcastle fans.

 

Silly Mackem gives game away he's a Mackem. 

[Alex 35068]

Classy chub

[Ayatollah Hermione 13862]

18 minutes ago, Christmas Tree said:

 

No, the difference between you and I is class. You have none. Can I suggest you reach for the ignore feature.

 

"Class"

 

From the bloke that brushed off Trophyshy's redundancy with absolutely no compassion. Not to mention that your favourite hobby is logging on here to wind people up about the things they're passionate about. When it was football, you could pass it off as you being a typical armchair gobshite but when it's politics or Brexit, and you're wilfully pushing people's anxieties over wages, healthcare and their children's futures, it crosses the line from harmless contrariness to you just being a grossly unlikable character. And then you come on with your photos of hot tubs or whatever that big paddling pool was and it becomes apparent that your whole out-facing personality is based directly on the most contemptible Tories imaginable. Hoping that a veneer of wacky purchases and Dear Diary bullshit ramblings help cover up a festering pit of genuinely detestable views and a total lack of empathy, understanding and a "I'm alright, Jack" stripe running right down your back.

[Renton 21594]

6 minutes ago, Ayatollah Hermione said:

 

"Class"

 

From the bloke that brushed off Trophyshy's redundancy with absolutely no compassion. Not to mention that your favourite hobby is logging on here to wind people up about the things they're passionate about. When it was football, you could pass it off as you being a typical armchair gobshite but when it's politics or Brexit, and you're wilfully pushing people's anxieties over wages, healthcare and their children's futures, it crosses the line from harmless contrariness to you just being a grossly unlikable character. And then you come on with your photos of hot tubs or whatever that big paddling pool was and it becomes apparent that your whole out-facing personality is based directly on the most contemptible Tories imaginable. Hoping that a veneer of wacky purchases and Dear Diary bullshit ramblings help cover up a festering pit of genuinely detestable views and a total lack of empathy, understanding and a "I'm alright, Jack" stripe running right down your back.

Ouch. I can sense a flounce coming. 

[Anorthernsoul 1221]

15 minutes ago, Ayatollah Hermione said:

 

"Class"

 

From the bloke that brushed off Trophyshy's redundancy with absolutely no compassion. Not to mention that your favourite hobby is logging on here to wind people up about the things they're passionate about. When it was football, you could pass it off as you being a typical armchair gobshite but when it's politics or Brexit, and you're wilfully pushing people's anxieties over wages, healthcare and their children's futures, it crosses the line from harmless contrariness to you just being a grossly unlikable character. And then you come on with your photos of hot tubs or whatever that big paddling pool was and it becomes apparent that your whole out-facing personality is based directly on the most contemptible Tories imaginable. Hoping that a veneer of wacky purchases and Dear Diary bullshit ramblings help cover up a festering pit of genuinely detestable views and a total lack of empathy, understanding and a "I'm alright, Jack" stripe running right down your back.

 

We're through the looking glass now folks.

[Monkeys Fist 42392]

49 minutes ago, Ayatollah Hermione said:

 

"Class"

 

From the bloke that brushed off Trophyshy's redundancy with absolutely no compassion. Not to mention that your favourite hobby is logging on here to wind people up about the things they're passionate about. When it was football, you could pass it off as you being a typical armchair gobshite but when it's politics or Brexit, and you're wilfully pushing people's anxieties over wages, healthcare and their children's futures, it crosses the line from harmless contrariness to you just being a grossly unlikable character. And then you come on with your photos of hot tubs or whatever that big paddling pool was and it becomes apparent that your whole out-facing personality is based directly on the most contemptible Tories imaginable. Hoping that a veneer of wacky purchases and Dear Diary bullshit ramblings help cover up a festering pit of genuinely detestable views and a total lack of empathy, understanding and a "I'm alright, Jack" stripe running right down your back.

Go on son! 

Right in the button mushroom. 

[ewerk 30571]

58 minutes ago, Ayatollah Hermione said:

 

"Class"

 

From the bloke that brushed off Trophyshy's redundancy with absolutely no compassion. Not to mention that your favourite hobby is logging on here to wind people up about the things they're passionate about. When it was football, you could pass it off as you being a typical armchair gobshite but when it's politics or Brexit, and you're wilfully pushing people's anxieties over wages, healthcare and their children's futures, it crosses the line from harmless contrariness to you just being a grossly unlikable character. And then you come on with your photos of hot tubs or whatever that big paddling pool was and it becomes apparent that your whole out-facing personality is based directly on the most contemptible Tories imaginable. Hoping that a veneer of wacky purchases and Dear Diary bullshit ramblings help cover up a festering pit of genuinely detestable views and a total lack of empathy, understanding and a "I'm alright, Jack" stripe running right down your back.

You could've saved yourself a bit of time and just described him as a Tory.