Shola Ameobi or Andy Carroll on sunday?

[loonyTOON 10]

Who do you think should start?

[Gejon 2]

Andy Carroll.

[Kevin S. Assilleekunt 1]

Both, it's at home, drop Nolan.

 

 

 

Routledge Barton Tiote Arfa

 

Shola Carroll

 

 

Should destroy them.

[JonGoodwyn 1]

I'd play both - we definitely should be playing Carroll for his aerial ability in defence alone, considering its Stoke

[Tom 14013]

Carroll

[loonyTOON 10]

Both, it's at home, drop Nolan.

 

 

 

Routledge Barton Tiote Arfa

 

Shola Carroll

 

 

Should destroy them.

 

Exactly what I was thinking. Carroll back tracks enough to act as Nolan, plus is quicker lol How many times we seen big Andy in defence? Scrap Nolan, and double our aerial threat

[Deano 0]

Both, it's at home, drop Nolan.

 

 

 

Routledge Barton Tiote Arfa

 

Shola Carroll

 

 

Should destroy them.

 

Exactly what I was thinking. Carroll back tracks enough to act as Nolan, plus is quicker lol How many times we seen big Andy in defence? Scrap Nolan, and double our aerial threat

 

 

Nice idea but have you forgot who our manager is?

[2bias 3]

LOL no votes for strola. Nice idea but one semi good game...na

[IrishMag 0]

Shola will start and have a shocker. Always happens after he does something decent.

[Marko 0]

Sholas done this all his career, had 1 good game every now and then but otherwise look average or poor. Stick with Carroll.

[Phil 6]

Shola is a total liability when defending corners (or in Stokes case throw ins). Nolan is physical and we'll need it. I'd also play Sol over Williams (as he was poor against Everton in the air).

[Monkeys Fist 43079]

Voted both, but in a straight choice between the two- Carroll every time.

[Dr Kenneth Noisewater 0]

Goala's had his good game for the season. He'll be shite again next time he gets on, I guarantee it.

[Dr Kenneth Noisewater 0]

Shola is a total liability when defending corners (or in Stokes case throw ins). Nolan is physical and we'll need it. I'd also play Sol over Williams (as he was poor against Everton in the air).

You must be fucking joking. Williamson won everything in the air on Saturday. That's why Fellaini was getting so frustrated. I thought he had a tremendous game.

[Tom 14013]

Ditto that.

 

Williamson is a rock.

[Ayatollah Hermione 14053]

Both, it's at home, drop Nolan.

 

 

 

Routledge Barton Tiote Arfa

 

Shola Carroll

 

 

Should destroy them.

 

Exactly what I was thinking. Carroll back tracks enough to act as Nolan, plus is quicker lol How many times we seen big Andy in defence? Scrap Nolan, and double our aerial threat

 

 

Nice idea but have you forgot who our manager is?

 

Aye, it's Hughton and he appears not to be as forgetful as you two.

[SloopJohn 0]

Carroll up front by himself

[ChezGiven 0]

Tell Carroll he gets dropped if he doesn't score against Stoke.

 

We aren't expected to get a point at city but the next 3 are big important games this season. You want them both as fired up as possible. That's shola's main problem though, he's not the sharpest of people or players. He does know how to beat the mackems though.

Edited September 23, 2010 by ChezGiven

[OTF 7492]

Ditto that.

 

Williamson is a rock.

 

He cost us a penalty against Chelsea courtesy of the reputation he gained from the Everton game where he had hands everywhere all over their players - most notably Fellaini and Beckford. You can't ge away with those sort of fouls for long before the referees really start cracking down on you and being overcritical - unless you are John Terry obviously.

 

Not saying that Campbell should start, though Hughton blatantly gave him game time with both Colo and Willo to see if they'd play well together. Campbell did do quite well, though I wasn't impressed with the height he had his shorts pulled up to. I know he's old, but really? THAT high?

[Tom 14013]

He cost us a penalty against Chelsea courtesy of the reputation he gained from the Everton game where he had hands everywhere all over their players - most notably Fellaini and Beckford. You can't ge away with those sort of fouls for long before the referees really start cracking down on you and being overcritical - unless you are John Terry obviously.

 

Fellaini was beating him to an inch of his life for fucks sake!

 

That penalty was nothing to do with reputation or anybody ''costing us'', nobody could see anything it as it was simply a top four giveaway.

 

Funny how you mentin being overcritical by the way

[sammynb 3508]

He cost us a penalty against Chelsea courtesy of the reputation he gained from the Everton game where he had hands everywhere all over their players - most notably Fellaini and Beckford. You can't ge away with those sort of fouls for long before the referees really start cracking down on you and being overcritical - unless you are John Terry obviously.

 

Fellaini was beating him to an inch of his life for fucks sake!

 

That penalty was nothing to do with reputation or anybody ''costing us'', nobody could see anything it as it was simply a top four giveaway.

 

Funny how you mentin being overcritical by the way

 

By the way if Williamson was the one that gave away the penalty then Kevin isn't a right royal cock.

Watch it again, Tiote has a cheeky grab on the way past him. Mind you with that twat refereeing he'd probably though Williamson has black paws.

[khay 10]

thought the pen was for Tiote running past him and trying to hug him tbh.

[Dr Gloom 22161]

shola should start on the bench. the same team that beat everton away should start again on sunday. the key to beating everton was winning the midfield battle. the same will probably apply to stoke.

[Park Life 71]

Option C.

[OTF 7492]

By the way if Williamson was the one that gave away the penalty then Kevin isn't a right royal cock.

Watch it again, Tiote has a cheeky grab on the way past him. Mind you with that twat refereeing he'd probably though Williamson has black paws.

 

The contact was definitely from Tiote on his way past, but the delayed nature of the dive meant that Willamson was on the scene when their player went down. Not a penalty obviously but I've got it in my head that it was called against Williamson, which makes it more blatantly wrong. I will watch it again and see if it changes my mind.

 

There's no denying however that against Everton Williamson was more handy than a Swiss army knife AND more handy than Mike Tyson in a strip joint. Good in the air and pretty good positionally, I think he's a solid defender especially considering his lack of experience. Doesn't deserve dropping for it, I don't think but may struggle against Stoke if they're overly physical up front.

Edited September 24, 2010 by OzToonFan