Jump to content

Phil Brown given the boot


Sonatine
 Share

Recommended Posts

No way in the world that Mark Hughes would even consider it. After being cleared out an Man City going to Hull and being relegated would be disasterous for his career.

 

Dowie is a more realistic shot.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 70
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I'm not in the loop here, so what's with the doubts about Hughton? From the casual outside observer he seems to be doing a good job. You could have brought back JFK and relly imploded.

 

General consensus seems to be that Hughton is doing nothing special, and that just about any manager would have yielded the same or similar results with the gulf in the class of players in this league. With that in mind if we're promoted the fear is that once the results don't come so easy the players heads will drop and Hughton won't be able to motivate them, or make the necessary tactical adjustments required.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not in the loop here, so what's with the doubts about Hughton? From the casual outside observer he seems to be doing a good job. You could have brought back JFK and relly imploded.

 

General consensus seems to be that Hughton is doing nothing special, and that just about any manager would have yielded the same or similar results with the gulf in the class of players in this league. With that in mind if we're promoted the fear is that once the results don't come so easy the players heads will drop and Hughton won't be able to motivate them, or make the necessary tactical adjustments required.

 

nicely put.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not in the loop here, so what's with the doubts about Hughton? From the casual outside observer he seems to be doing a good job. You could have brought back JFK and relly imploded.

 

General consensus seems to be that Hughton is doing nothing special, and that just about any manager would have yielded the same or similar results with the gulf in the class of players in this league. With that in mind if we're promoted the fear is that once the results don't come so easy the players heads will drop and Hughton won't be able to motivate them, or make the necessary tactical adjustments required.

 

Good summary. Plus he lacks the cohones to stand up to Fat Mike and the Casino Cruiser on re-shaping the squad.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

they have a few winnable fixtures left, might stay up due to the other shite teams, might not. Pretty much no-one i'd want here (apart from an injury free Bullard) off their team which says it all really.

Edited by TicTacWoe
Link to comment
Share on other sites

they have a few winnable fixtures left, might stay up due to the other shite teams, might not. Pretty much no-one i'd want here (apart from an injury free Bullard) off their team which says it all really.

 

Agree with that, though for me Bullard would have to be injury free and shave off at least a couple of years (and the hair).

 

There's a few people in Nigeria that will be able to help him with the years no doubt.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not in the loop here, so what's with the doubts about Hughton? From the casual outside observer he seems to be doing a good job. You could have brought back JFK and relly imploded.

 

General consensus seems to be that Hughton is doing nothing special, and that just about any manager would have yielded the same or similar results with the gulf in the class of players in this league. With that in mind if we're promoted the fear is that once the results don't come so easy the players heads will drop and Hughton won't be able to motivate them, or make the necessary tactical adjustments required.

 

 

its frightening to think the frenzy that would have been generated had Shearer been in charge and acheived exactly the same results. I admit I would have probably lost all perspective and be considering him some sort of management god, rather than Hughton who is being shrugged off as a innefectual bloke who got lucky.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not in the loop here, so what's with the doubts about Hughton? From the casual outside observer he seems to be doing a good job. You could have brought back JFK and relly imploded.

 

General consensus seems to be that Hughton is doing nothing special, and that just about any manager would have yielded the same or similar results with the gulf in the class of players in this league. With that in mind if we're promoted the fear is that once the results don't come so easy the players heads will drop and Hughton won't be able to motivate them, or make the necessary tactical adjustments required.

 

 

its frightening to think the frenzy that would have been generated had Shearer been in charge and acheived exactly the same results. I admit I would have probably lost all perspective and be considering him some sort of management god, rather than Hughton who is being shrugged off as a innefectual bloke who got lucky.

 

I think it's the manner of performances that has people worried. All too often, Hughton's been tactically suspect and we've really had to grind results out sometimes. If Shearer was here with the same points total and the same performances, I think people would be a bit concerned as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not in the loop here, so what's with the doubts about Hughton? From the casual outside observer he seems to be doing a good job. You could have brought back JFK and relly imploded.

 

General consensus seems to be that Hughton is doing nothing special, and that just about any manager would have yielded the same or similar results with the gulf in the class of players in this league. With that in mind if we're promoted the fear is that once the results don't come so easy the players heads will drop and Hughton won't be able to motivate them, or make the necessary tactical adjustments required.

 

 

its frightening to think the frenzy that would have been generated had Shearer been in charge and acheived exactly the same results. I admit I would have probably lost all perspective and be considering him some sort of management god, rather than Hughton who is being shrugged off as a innefectual bloke who got lucky.

 

I think it's the manner of performances that has people worried. All too often, Hughton's been tactically suspect and we've really had to grind results out sometimes. If Shearer was here with the same points total and the same performances, I think people would be a bit concerned as well.

 

What I would say is that Hughton has done exactly what it takes to get out of this division, he's built from the back and he's not lost many games. Yes one or two decisions have been suspect but he's made the team very difficult to beat and instilled a fighting spirit that was long since gone.

 

I think anybody that witnessed the shambles that was Aston Villa on the last day of the season must have serious concerns over Shearer's ability to motivate players. To go out in the manner that we did was an absolute disgrace.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Will this make him the only (assistant) manager to relegate two teams from the Premier League in the space of one year?

 

:yes

 

I seem to remember Dave Bassett doing it twice in one season, though not in the PL.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not in the loop here, so what's with the doubts about Hughton? From the casual outside observer he seems to be doing a good job. You could have brought back JFK and relly imploded.

 

General consensus seems to be that Hughton is doing nothing special, and that just about any manager would have yielded the same or similar results with the gulf in the class of players in this league. With that in mind if we're promoted the fear is that once the results don't come so easy the players heads will drop and Hughton won't be able to motivate them, or make the necessary tactical adjustments required.

 

 

its frightening to think the frenzy that would have been generated had Shearer been in charge and acheived exactly the same results. I admit I would have probably lost all perspective and be considering him some sort of management god, rather than Hughton who is being shrugged off as a innefectual bloke who got lucky.

 

I think it's the manner of performances that has people worried. All too often, Hughton's been tactically suspect and we've really had to grind results out sometimes. If Shearer was here with the same points total and the same performances, I think people would be a bit concerned as well.

 

What I would say is that Hughton has done exactly what it takes to get out of this division, he's built from the back and he's not lost many games. Yes one or two decisions have been suspect but he's made the team very difficult to beat and instilled a fighting spirit that was long since gone.

 

I think anybody that witnessed the shambles that was Aston Villa on the last day of the season must have serious concerns over Shearer's ability to motivate players. To go out in the manner that we did was an absolute disgrace.

It's a fair point.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not in the loop here, so what's with the doubts about Hughton? From the casual outside observer he seems to be doing a good job. You could have brought back JFK and relly imploded.

 

General consensus seems to be that Hughton is doing nothing special, and that just about any manager would have yielded the same or similar results with the gulf in the class of players in this league. With that in mind if we're promoted the fear is that once the results don't come so easy the players heads will drop and Hughton won't be able to motivate them, or make the necessary tactical adjustments required.

 

 

its frightening to think the frenzy that would have been generated had Shearer been in charge and acheived exactly the same results. I admit I would have probably lost all perspective and be considering him some sort of management god, rather than Hughton who is being shrugged off as a innefectual bloke who got lucky.

 

I think it's the manner of performances that has people worried. All too often, Hughton's been tactically suspect and we've really had to grind results out sometimes. If Shearer was here with the same points total and the same performances, I think people would be a bit concerned as well.

 

What I would say is that Hughton has done exactly what it takes to get out of this division, he's built from the back and he's not lost many games. Yes one or two decisions have been suspect but he's made the team very difficult to beat and instilled a fighting spirit that was long since gone.

 

I think anybody that witnessed the shambles that was Aston Villa on the last day of the season must have serious concerns over Shearer's ability to motivate players. To go out in the manner that we did was an absolute disgrace.

It's a fair point.

 

Personally speaking, I think Hughton has done a pretty good job for you. After the complete shitstorm of relegation, the wages of planks like Viduka, and the fact of who you're owned by it could have been one hell of a plunge. You may have even been relegated again with that sense of doom and gloom around your club at the end of last season. Hughton seems to have got some of the confidence back up there, and whilst you probably won't challenge for Europe with the current set-up, at least you have the momentum to not be considered automatic relegation candidates. It could have been a lot worse-JFK or Dennis Wise could have taken over once Alan left.

 

As for Dowie, there are rumours of his training methods being 'traditional' along with his man-management skills. I doubt he can keep them up. They are in a real tailspin, and have 1st division players playing for them.

Edited by Billy Castell
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 6 months later...
  • 3 months later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.