Milner scores winner

[Guest alex]

ps: i do rememeber seeing zoggy playing well iwhen he had a run of games in the centre of midfield. i'm not backing down from that - i just can't remember which season it was. there's no pretence on my part.

 

but you do rate alan smith therefore nothing you say can be taken serioulsy

You only made two points there but they're both bollocks.

The run of games never happened - you said it was on the left of a middle three originally by the way. And I no longer rate Smith although before he came I thought he was a canny player. Nice try though.

 

you rated smith, so you lose

Keegan rates Smith btw.

Ok, you should be able to remember a few details. Who were the opponents? Where did you watch these games? What impressed you about N’Zogbia in these performances? Who was the manager? Who was he playing in midfield alongside? Etc. etc.

I wouldn’t expect you to know all these things but the odd thing like that would convince me a bit. Given it couldn’t have happened that long ago.

Unless you made it up.

 

keegan rating smith is a concern to me - it should be to you too if you care about the club. the kid is absolute garbage.

 

to be absolutely frank mate, i couldn't really give a monkeys whether you think i'm making it up. and like i said in the other thread, i can't remember those details - i'm pretty sure it was at the tail end of a recent season - under either roeder or souness (the season before one or the other of them got sacked)... i seem to remember us going on a nice little run which led us to midtable safety with zoggy playing well in centre mid. iirc as part of a midfield 3.

 

you know i live in london and don't have a season ticket. i watch the matches on sky, the internet the odd home game when i'm back up north and away games in london when i can. i'm not trying to convince you of otherwise or that i'm an uber-soopa-fan but i do try and keep on top of what's going on and i'm not making stuff up to some random bloke on a message board - why would i?

 

oh yeah - and nice one for hitting me where it hurts: my knowledge of the under 21s.

 

you on the other hand admitted yourself that you rated smith when he arrived. i'll leave it there

That's me convinced you weren't talking rubbish

How does watching the games on Sky or on the internet make it any more believable that you saw these games? The ones where N'Zogbia had a spell playing well in the middle (or on the left of a midfield 3, depending on your mood). You can't even can't remember a single detail from the games in question? Ok.

I'll leave it at that.

[Dr Gloom 22509]

and the last word goes to:

 

smith

[Guest alex]

At least I admitted I was wrong about that.

[Dr Gloom 22509]

At least I admitted I was wrong about that.

 

i'm not admitting that i'm making stuff up because i'm not.

 

i'm sure i remember zoggy playing well for us for a few games in centre mid a few seasons back. of course i might be wrong, my memory isn't the best. but i'm not deliberately making things up - what would i gain by doing that?

 

alex, you're a funny bloke but i find you a little strange. you seem to take a perverse pleasure in striking up petty arguments. plus you rated alan smith so i win

[Guest alex]

At least I admitted I was wrong about that.

 

i'm not admitting that i'm making stuff up because i'm not.

 

i'm sure i remember zoggy playing well for us for a few games in centre mid a few seasons back. of course i might be wrong, my memory isn't the best. but i'm not deliberately making things up - what would i gain by doing that?

 

alex, you're a funny bloke but i find you a little strange. you seem to take a perverse pleasure in striking up petty arguments. plus you rated alan smith so i win

I think you were trying to show you had some knowledge rather than just posting with a rain cloud over your head moaning about x,y or z. You failed though because the run of games never took place. No one's memory is as bad as that man unless they've got a genuine problem in that area. Which tbf, you can't have or you wouldn't be able to remember posts I made about Smith. Nice try though with the 'my memory isn't the best' thing. I asked you to name one little detail about the said games man, not a detailed analysis on every performance.

[Guest alex]

Btw Dan, didn't you rate the likes of Barton, Geremi and Duff?

[Dr Gloom 22509]

At least I admitted I was wrong about that.

 

i'm not admitting that i'm making stuff up because i'm not.

 

i'm sure i remember zoggy playing well for us for a few games in centre mid a few seasons back. of course i might be wrong, my memory isn't the best. but i'm not deliberately making things up - what would i gain by doing that?

 

alex, you're a funny bloke but i find you a little strange. you seem to take a perverse pleasure in striking up petty arguments. plus you rated alan smith so i win

I think you were trying to show you had some knowledge rather than just posting with a rain cloud over your head moaning about x,y or z. You failed though because the run of games never took place. No one's memory is as bad as that man unless they've got a genuine problem in that area. Which tbf, you can't have or you wouldn't be able to remember posts I made about Smith. Nice try though with the 'my memory isn't the best' thing. I asked you to name one little detail about the said games man, not a detailed analysis on every performance.

 

how do you equate me saying i thought zoggy looked good in the middle to moaning or posting with a rain cloud over my head?

 

like i said, i can't remember exactly when this run of games was or the exact detail (please forgive me) - though i do seem to remember it being either the tailend of a season either under roeder or souness when we rallied at the end of the year, had a few inuries and played a new system with three in the middle - zoggy being one of them and iirc emre and one other alongside him with duff and milner out wide. if you don't want to believe me, fair dos. just seems a strange thing to try and pick a fight with me over on a totally unrelated thread.

 

and hey look, i might be wrong. maybe we can put this to the rest of the board to see if anyone else can remember it or if it's a total mistake on my part. maybe it was one game... i remember (perhaps wrongly) it was a little run of games. but even if i am wrong, i'm not trying to make things up. i find the fact that you think otherwise a little troubling.

 

and nice try on seeing how many times you can include nice try in one of your posts. i might try that myself more often.

[Guest alex]

http://www.toontastic.net/board/index.php?...st&p=380069

[Guest alex]

At least I admitted I was wrong about that.

 

i'm not admitting that i'm making stuff up because i'm not.

 

i'm sure i remember zoggy playing well for us for a few games in centre mid a few seasons back. of course i might be wrong, my memory isn't the best. but i'm not deliberately making things up - what would i gain by doing that?

 

alex, you're a funny bloke but i find you a little strange. you seem to take a perverse pleasure in striking up petty arguments. plus you rated alan smith so i win

I think you were trying to show you had some knowledge rather than just posting with a rain cloud over your head moaning about x,y or z. You failed though because the run of games never took place. No one's memory is as bad as that man unless they've got a genuine problem in that area. Which tbf, you can't have or you wouldn't be able to remember posts I made about Smith. Nice try though with the 'my memory isn't the best' thing. I asked you to name one little detail about the said games man, not a detailed analysis on every performance.

 

how do you equate me saying i thought zoggy looked good in the middle to moaning or posting with a rain cloud over my head?

 

like i said, i can't remember exactly when this run of games was or the exact detail (please forgive me) - though i do seem to remember it being either the tailend of a season either under roeder or souness when we rallied at the end of the year, had a few inuries and played a new system with three in the middle - zoggy being one of them and iirc emre and one other alongside him with duff and milner out wide. if you don't want to believe me, fair dos. just seems a strange thing to try and pick a fight with me over on a totally unrelated thread.

 

and hey look, i might be wrong. maybe we can put this to the rest of the board to see if anyone else can remember it or if it's a total mistake on my part. maybe it was one game... i remember (perhaps wrongly) it was a little run of games. but even if i am wrong, i'm not trying to make things up. i find the fact that you think otherwise a little troubling.

 

and nice try on seeing how many times you can include nice try in one of your posts. i might try that myself more often.

I brought it up because you brought Smith up. Unrelated to the thread. You brought that up because I had a dig to be fair. I've posted that team up to show how you get things wrong as well.

[Dr Gloom 22509]

At least I admitted I was wrong about that.

 

i'm not admitting that i'm making stuff up because i'm not.

 

i'm sure i remember zoggy playing well for us for a few games in centre mid a few seasons back. of course i might be wrong, my memory isn't the best. but i'm not deliberately making things up - what would i gain by doing that?

 

alex, you're a funny bloke but i find you a little strange. you seem to take a perverse pleasure in striking up petty arguments. plus you rated alan smith so i win

I think you were trying to show you had some knowledge rather than just posting with a rain cloud over your head moaning about x,y or z. You failed though because the run of games never took place. No one's memory is as bad as that man unless they've got a genuine problem in that area. Which tbf, you can't have or you wouldn't be able to remember posts I made about Smith. Nice try though with the 'my memory isn't the best' thing. I asked you to name one little detail about the said games man, not a detailed analysis on every performance.

 

how do you equate me saying i thought zoggy looked good in the middle to moaning or posting with a rain cloud over my head?

 

like i said, i can't remember exactly when this run of games was or the exact detail (please forgive me) - though i do seem to remember it being either the tailend of a season either under roeder or souness when we rallied at the end of the year, had a few inuries and played a new system with three in the middle - zoggy being one of them and iirc emre and one other alongside him with duff and milner out wide. if you don't want to believe me, fair dos. just seems a strange thing to try and pick a fight with me over on a totally unrelated thread.

 

and hey look, i might be wrong. maybe we can put this to the rest of the board to see if anyone else can remember it or if it's a total mistake on my part. maybe it was one game... i remember (perhaps wrongly) it was a little run of games. but even if i am wrong, i'm not trying to make things up. i find the fact that you think otherwise a little troubling.

 

and nice try on seeing how many times you can include nice try in one of your posts. i might try that myself more often.

I brought it up because you brought Smith up. Unrelated to the thread. You brought that up because I had a dig to be fair. I've posted that team up to show how you get things wrong as well.

 

that is a woeful selection tbf, i'm not denying that. although speaks volumes for the players in our squad...especially the fact that barton probably plays when everyone is fit