Rayvin

We need to win the argument with the hard left first.. leaders later. We need to avoid the party falling apart.

How do we wrestle control off Momentum? Sign up to Labour now, if you want to change anything.

Step 1 - get a centrist, safe Blairite into power with loads of safe policies and a promise to implement PR. Step 2 - do all the left wing shit next time out cos under PR it looks a lot better: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/general-election-results-pr-alternative-voting-system-tories-labour-hung-a9246661.html

I also think the plan was too much. But I think it was clear that they had no expectation of winning power and implementing any of it. I actually think they worked out early doors that this election was going to be a disaster.

I'd readily take a Blair if it was one with a stronger commitment to left wing views concerning capitalism and the environment. Late stage-capitalism is killing the world at this point, and centrism just isn't going to fix that fast enough. I appreciate that we can't manage to get the public to agree that the left is the answer but whoever we put forward needs to appear centrist and push as far left as they can get away with. And more than anything else, they need to reform the political system to prevent the Tories ever getting back in, even if that means that Labour never get a majority again either. Wouldn't hurt for them to work on properly educating people either.

Going to sleep now. I'll be out like a light tbh. Enjoy your shows

Protest against what.. it was a democratic exercise, it's just how it is.

FFS

It isn't a majority of countrymen Just seats.

Still here. Been watching all the right wing Tory boys infecting comment sections all over the place. One just told me that I had been humiliated and that he wanted to see that I would learn that not everything was the Tories fault, and that because the electorate had rejected it, my worldview was therefore wrong. I have to say, from a position of almost total apathy, that little fuckwit might have returned the fire to my belly a bit...

I just dont see the point now, may as well just get an early night later

Was that post incoherent..?

Don't despair just yet. If they don't let Scotland go then we have one final chance at this in 5 years. The price will probably be Scottish independence so we literally only get one shot. The Tories are still useless, and a non useless Labour leader could make the difference. If they get in, bring about PR, change press rules, then we can stop this happening ever again. Brexit is a poisoned chalice still. It just depends on what Labour does next.

Cooper seems to be irrationally hated. I've asked why because i don't get it. Thornberry would be good, would be happy with that.

Also many will have lent their votes to other parties. Just checked the Labour forum on Facebook and Starmer looks popular. Along with JLB though.

Part of me hopes that several of the Labour voters who went for the Tories this time have a nagging sense of "what have we done". I doubt the intention was a victory this convincing. They'll know what Johnson is about, too. I still think that anyone objecting to Corbyn has no need to go Tory. So many of them went straight across the aisle here it's just bizarre if the issue was just him.

But they do matter to the left wing that any centrist taking over Labour needs to keep on side. This whole point came from an attempt to suggest that if the centrists do somehow manage to take control again, they need to keep the left on board. Somehow.

I'm not trying to put lipstick on anything, I think they're fucked. Permanently. I've said it repeatedly.

Also, again, I'm kind of trying to suggest how we get the broad church back. I'm now about 30 hours without sleep so maybe I'm totally incoherent at this point.

Johnson just won an election, that's not going to help us. Just winning isn't everything. Policies matter.

I didn't say it was, hence suggesting we leave austerity out. All i meant to imply was that the offering needs to be strong. More left than centre.

So how are you proposing we get the left on board with austerity lite? Maybe we leave that particular policy on the bonfire. I wonder if all of this could have been avoided if Labour just opposed austerity properly... maybe Corbyn would never have been elected. As I've said before, I was going Cooper up until I read his manifesto and the party broadly voted to punish poor people in some timely vote on austerity around the same time. But anyway, if the centrists want to take the party back, it's gonna have to be seriously convincing stuff. Winning elections should be front and centre but it can't be everything.

It's a right mess unless we literally have the second coming of Blair around the corner, with enough despair on the left to wave it through. Who knows I guess but i don't think it looks good.

I think a centrist, media friendly pro Remain leader would have done far better, but probably still lost a decent number of the hard-core leave seats. Maybe they would have picked up enough Tory ones to counter that, idk. I'm talking now about the future of the party though. Whether you think Younge or any of the Corbyn faithful are right or not, it is clear that they do not see this as a defeat for left wing policy. And their policy research will support that, since they received broadly favourable results. The consequence of that view, is that Labour is doomed. If it goes centrist, the left will schism out (And they are not so small in number that Labour don't need them). If it goes left, the centre leave and have to vaguely try to establish an electoral force in the same place as the Lib Dems who have proven once again that they're on a hiding to nothing but can at least win a reasonable number of centrist votes - or to join with them and further alienate the soft left. The only chance for Labour is the broad church, and it isn't happening.

I'm not saying the left is right about all this btw, I'm just saying that schism is inevitable and neither side will win.